Two Waves, One Childhood, Part One — The Race for Attention
Two Waves, One Childhood, Part One — The Race for Attention
I was recently rewatching The A.I. Dilemma from the Center for Humane Technology. I really like their approach because I’m always looking for a new way to look at things. In the presentation, Tristan Harris and Aza Raskin describe two ways AI entered our everyday lives, which I think of as two waves. The first came through social media, where AI learned what to show us next to keep us scrolling. They called it the “race to the bottom of the brainstem.” The second came with generative AI, where the technology could talk back. They called that the “race to intimacy.”
This week, I want to talk about that first wave. How did social media get so good at keeping us scrolling, and what does that look like for kids growing up with it? Is the wave still starting to curl, or has it already hit the shore?
Why do social media platforms want our attention?
So let’s do some basic marketing psychology 101. The longer we stay on social media, the more chances the platform has to show us an ad. There’s an old saying that if something is free, you’re the product. I just wanted an online yearbook when Facebook started in 2004. In 2025, Meta, the company behind Facebook and Instagram, brought in $196.2 billion in advertising revenue. Turns out there was a little more money in this than yearbook sales.
Take a scroll through Facebook or Instagram and see how often you spot the word “Sponsored.” We’ve gotten so used to ads that half the time I’m already looking for the X before I know what’s being advertised. And who decided that the X should be approximately the size of a grain of salt?
When did Facebook introduce infinite scroll?
According to a New York City court filing, Facebook began using infinite scroll around 2010, first for photos. It later brought the feature to the News Feed. Remember when you got to the bottom of the posts and there weren’t any new ones? Yeah, me either. Once more posts started loading on their own, one of our natural stopping points disappeared.
How do algorithms keep us scrolling?
So how do they keep us interested in a feed that never ends? Let me introduce you to the algorithm. Every time you pause on a video, watch it again, or swipe past it, you give the platform a clue about what holds your attention. Infinite scroll gives you another post. The algorithm tries to pick one you’ll stick around for.
That next post can be funny, fascinating, or absolutely infuriating. By 2020, we had a word for when the news kept getting worse and we kept scrolling anyway. We called it doomscrolling.
What does this look like in a kid’s life?
Scroll. Compare. Perform. Count likes. Measure popularity. When the more provocative, violent, sexualized, or drama-filled posts get the most attention, kids can pick up on that pretty quickly. And when it’s their turn to post, they may feel pressure to turn it up a little more just to get noticed.
Then there’s the pull of everybody else’s world. Get ready with me. Buy this product. Learn this dance. Here’s a storytime. Here’s somebody trauma dumping to strangers. And here’s another challenge, because apparently we were running low.
Who can forget the Tide Pod Challenge? It went viral in January 2018, and by mid-month Tide had put out a public service announcement with Rob Gronkowski telling people to leave the laundry detergent out of their diet. I’m pretty sure nobody had that on their bingo card.
What are the mental health and social costs we need to watch for in kids?
Anxiety. Distraction. Constant comparison. Polarization. Less time socializing in person. More fear around starting a conversation. More difficulty forming relationships. The list goes on. I worry about what happens when kids have fewer chances to practice the awkward stuff that comes with getting to know people. Saying hello first. Sitting through a little silence. Finding out you can disagree with somebody and still be friends.
I think one of our unintentional mistakes as adults is saying, “It’s just a phone,” or “It’s just a dance on TikTok. What’s the big deal?” Sometimes it really is just a dance. A kid learns it, has fun with it, and posts it hoping their friends will laugh or do it too. If that video is public on TikTok or Instagram, the audience can include grown men that kid has never met. Some may watch a child’s video for reasons the child never imagined when they hit post.
We spend a lot of time asking what kids are watching. I think we also need to ask who might be watching them. Who did they picture seeing the video? Who can actually see it? I’d pull up the privacy settings together and start there.
Did the first wave hit the shore?
I think it did. I used to think of this mainly as something adults and teens were dealing with. Now I see pieces of it showing up with elementary-age kids, too. When I see younger kids making “get ready with me” videos, I think about how Jonathan Haidt describes the shift from a play-based childhood to a phone-based childhood. It makes me wonder how much time kids still get to make up a game in the grass with their friends and change the rules halfway through because somebody’s losing.
We can start small. The next time a kid shows you a video, watch it with them and ask, “What made you stop on that one?” You might get a laugh, learn something about what they like, and give them a chance to notice what grabs their attention. And there’s still time to go outside and make up a game with terrible rules.
Next week, I’ll look at the second wave. What happens when the technology that learned how to hold a kid’s attention can talk back, and the kid starts turning to it for company? That’s the race to intimacy.
~Ryan